Letter to Sr. Sheila Browne, RSM, Assistant Director of Worship for the Diocese of Rockville Center, NY

Dear Sr. Sheila,

It never ceases to amaze me. No matter how many times I have heard priests preaching blatant heresy from the pulpit, no one has stood up. Priests engage in acts of scandal, and are reported to their diocese, and the diocese don’t act. But let a priest stand up for reverence for the Blessed Sacrament, and watch out! Diocesan reaction is swift and brutal.

Having never heard of the so-called Federation of Diocesan Liturgical Commissions (exactly which Vatican curia is that), I would rather go by the advice of our prefect emeritus of Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, Francis Cardinal Arinze, who said that he’d prefer if all priests distributed Holy Communion by intinction: a method which is a) given preference in the GIRM over reception by hand; b) reserved to priests alone (eliminating the “need” for extraordinary ministers) and c) only done by tongue.

Certainly, reception on the tongue is no guarantee of reverence for the Sacred Body. I have twice witnessed priests pursuing congregants who did not visibly pursue the Host. The first time, it was three very immodestly dressed young women, who made jokes all through Mass. Only two went up for Communion. One went to the priest, who stopped Communion and ordered her to relinquish the Host that she did not immediately consume. The other girl went to an ECM and, when she got back to the pew in front of us, she and the other girls “huddled” and looked at an object in her hands.

Another occasion was at a parish where the priest distributed Communion by intinction. Eucharistic descration by Satanists has gone on throughout history, so obviously reception on the tongue is not a complete solution.

Nevertheless, there can be no doubt that reception on the hand—an indult granted originally to North America on an experimental basis and never a direct intention of Vatican II—has resulted in a great rise of both irreverence towards and outright desecration of the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ. Consider the nun who said to Mother Angelica, “You’re one of those ‘cookie worshippers,’ aren’t you?” Or the Sister who said to participants in Eucharist Adoration at my old parish: “Jesus is just as present in that garden as He is in this Church!”

People approach the altar in various states of undress (such as the aforementioned teenaged girls, who were wearing see-through tops with colored bras), chewing gum, etc. Polls show that most Catholics see greater importance in the Signum Pacis than in Holy Communion.

In most parishes, almost every person sitting in Church goes to Communion on Sunday, but how many are lined up for Confession on Saturday afternoon?But let a priest or deacon preach about respect for the Blessed Sacrament, and look out! The parish goes into an uproar about how “backwards” and “uncompassionate” he is!
Let a priest or a deacon actually call for acts of reverence towards the Blessed Sacrament, and he gets a slap-down from the Bishop himself, or, worse ,from a low-level diocesan bureaucrat who isn’t even ordained clergy.

I don’t see how a Bride of Christ can have so little reverence for His Body.

6 responses to “Letter to Sr. Sheila Browne, RSM, Assistant Director of Worship for the Diocese of Rockville Center, NY

  1. Get a life.

  2. John C. Hathaway

    Strange comment. I was unaware that there are blogs written by zombies.

    Let me see, you are either,
    1. Some anti-Catholic person of any stripe who thinks reverence for the Eucharist is just plain silly but will jump at any perceived fault of the Church,
    2. Some liberal Catholic who thinks reverence for the Eucharist is just plain silly but will jump at any perceived fault of the Church.
    3. A supporter of this Sr. Sheila person,
    4. Sr. Sheila herself.

    However, given your anonymity and your completely useless comment, it is clear you are not interested in engaging in dialogue, but merely insult, which only demonstrates the weakness of your own position, whatever that may be.

    I would just delete your comment if it were not such an amusing example of how “sin makes you stupid.”

  3. Dear Sr Shelia i grew up in brooklyn in St.Agatha parish i had you for cdd i always looked up to you as a young child now i am in my mid 40s i was even going take your name for confrimation , I am praying for all the sisters in there time need and Sr Jackie walsh will be in my prayers too

  4. I take it you support desecration of the Eucharist as well?

  5. This letter I wrote was in response to a case where a priest did his duty and banned reception on the hand in his parish (if you try to receive by the hand from the Holy Father, Swiss Guards will instruct you otherwise). This modernist nun ordered the priest to allow Communion on the hand.

  6. And I take it given your comment about “Sisters in their time of need” that you support the open rebellion of habitless nuns against the Vatican’s authority?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s