A tale of two doctors

One of the wisest people I know suggested the following analogy.

Imagine you have a choice between two doctors. You know one doctor is more intelligent, and that he has the treatment that will help you. The treatment will keep you alive but you have to use it over and over the rest of your life. It won’t be pleasant, and may indeed be unpleasant, but it will work. However, he is hard to work with, his office staff have no customer service skills, hound you about money as soon as you come in the door, and they all seem more concerned about their careers than your health. The waiting and exam rooms are drab, with medical journals all over the place, some really old, and poor music.
The other doctor is friendly. His office is stylish, up-to-date, with big screen TVs in the waiting and exam rooms. The staff are courteous and friendly. He offers you a quick fix solution that will be one, not so unpleasant, treatment that you know is a placebo at best and proverbial “snake oil” at worst.
Now, obviously, if you can find someone with the positive traits of both, that’s who you would go with, but if it came down to A or B, would you really choose the charlatan because the experience seemed more pleasant?

Then why do the same thing with your spiritual health?

Why say, “I believe the Church’s teachings are true, but there’s too much corruption in the hierarchy, and the Mass is boring. The Evangelical Mega-Church down the street has better music, a friendlier pastor and staff, and all sorts of activities. Besides, they tell me all I have to do is have faith in Jesus.”


2 responses to “A tale of two doctors

  1. “All analogies limp” but the comparison may be useful as this “tale of two doctors.” At the heart of the spiritual malaise are who we ‘make’ God to be in our image or the reverse. Saint Paul who was caught up into heaven said, “What no eye has seen, nor ear heard, nor the heart of man imagined,
    what God has prepared for those who love him”— these things God has revealed to us through the Spirit. (1 Cor. 2:9-10). Our faith, our religion, originates with God not ourselves. It is supernatural above our natural ability
    to know and love God, a gift man can pervert. We suffer today in and outside of church the disorder of egocentrism and androcentrism except we
    . . . do die in this world.

    Faith is empty which does not include hope and love of God who transcends man but, mystery of mysteries, the Son of God as only God could do raised our nature to his one being, the story of Christmas. The story whose conclusion Jesus sanctified on the cross accepting the hard things of this world for the joy of a better life to come which includes “corruption in the hierarchy, and the Mass is boring” in this world etcetera.

    • Yet Aquinas teaches that all theology is analogy, since our brains are incapable of truly comprehending it. 🙂
      Otherwise, beautiful comment, thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s